Indianapolis has a theater scene which includes New Plays Indy — The New Harmony Project. Now, if I could find a way to see some of it. It looks like local talent is also writing plays that are produced.
Meet six historical reenactors bringing Indiana history to life.
Shareef played one of the first characters for Freetown Village, a history museum that tours around the state. It was founded by Ophelia Wellington in 1982.
He played Isaiah Cuffee, a barber from the year 1870 in Indianapolis. Wellington developed the character using U.S. Census records and books. Wellington remembers Shareef shaking on stage at first, but bringing the character to life, whom she said he emulated, anyway.
From there, Freetown created other composite characters, including teachers, ministers and attorneys.
***
Elaine Sholty was introduced to the living history scene in the early 1990s. She and her husband were leaving a movie theater after catching “Gettysburg,” featuring Richard Jordan and Martin Sheen. On the way out, they passed a group of Civil War reenactors with a canon prop.
The couple began doing reenactments together as a hobby. Sholty portrayed northern and southern women of the Civil War era in her mid-century day dresses — at places such as Crown Hill Cemetery. At a gun salute, she met members of Daughters of the American Revolution, where she is now the Indianapolis chapter president.
***
Most elementary school students on field trips to Conner Prairie come into contact with historical interpreters. Interpretation coordinator Anne Coffey plans all programming on the historic grounds at the museum in Fishers. She also plays a few characters such as Mrs. Whitaker. Mrs. Whitaker is loud and outgoing, and her husband owns a general store set in 1836.
Coffey said all of the characters in Prairie Town are composite characters, meaning they’re not based on one real person, but a mix of facts and of perspectives of people who lived in Hamilton County during the 1830s.
***
Actors Donnice Robinson and Tracey Wynn met in 2019 while working as characters in the Madam C.J. Walker exhibit at the Indiana Historical Society. Wynn played Madam C.J. Walker, and Robinson portrayed Candace Pinkston, who was one of Walker’s sales agents.
When the exhibit closed, the duo didn’t want to see “those people go to sleep.” In 2022, they founded Soulful Journeys of Women. The company has a contract with the Indianapolis Public Library to perform History on Stage.
***
Tristan Ross has always been a “history dork.” Even his email address calls on the Danish astronomer Tycho Brahe known for making the most accurate astronomical observations before the invention of the telescope. He described his previous role as an interpreter and facilitator at the Indiana Historical Society for eight years as “a spoonful of sugar that helped the lesson go down.”
“For the past decades, the humanities have been an academic punching bag ever since STEM became a hot button thing. There is a lot of wisdom to be gleaned from what has happened in the past,” he said.




















































































