Friday, November 13, 2026

The Middle Of The Week: Writing, Church, PO, Chava's Finally

 Wednesday went a good day until it turned into a disaster.

I worked on the novella Wednesday but I had a plan for CC. It was to get her to Vespers. She needs a place where she could have some peace and safety and quiet. Well, I did not tell her where we were going. All I had asked for was two hours. 

Logistics raised its ugly head. A taxi for her to my place, a bus to St. Baranabas, and a taxi for her home. Only she was running behind. I had the taxi take her to the church. Then I walked over, rapidly, since I did not know if she had cash for the driver. By the time I made the walk, my ankles screamed and I was sweaty. This I need to do more of. She was from happy and I got a bit more unhappy. We kept leaving the sanctuary when we went back in for the last time, I think she got some of what I had hoped for. She got a call - another crisis. I decided she has more crises than Gordon Ramsey during a dinner rush. She left not so angry at me. I told the priest I had need of another confession. Oh, plans went wrong. It always goes that way with me plan to do something good and it falls apart. Blunder into something, that is me. And a danger to the Republic.

I walked back, during which I called KH. He said he would call me back that night. It was about an hour later and we talked as we usually do - too long. Besides politics, it was about the novella. He is the one who has me doubting its worth. He has read the first two chapters, he told me that it was working and not self-indulgent silliness. Me, I think it works and the writing is pretty good. Such self-confidence should have worried.

Thursday started good enough. I got through some odds and ends before getting to the novella. Then my neck started locking up. I laid down down around 11 and then was awakened before noon by the PO visiting.

Again, it was both of them. I am still not sure why the old one comes along. He was supposed to have taken on a new area. Supervision? They stayed for about five minutes asking if all was well. Neither has quite understood life is quite good for me. I have tried not to hurt either's feelings by letting them insofar as their job is to help integrate me back into society, but neither has seemed competent enough to help me there. The new one did comment that it must be nice to be able to take a nap in the middle of the day. He said nothing further when I mentioned I had been up since 7.

The lie down worked well enough for the neck, but energy was a little low. I talked to CC on the phone. Having run out of cigarettes, I headed to the convenience store.  I ran into the bus on the way there. Instead of going to the store and back, I went to Chava's in The Village and had aburrito. It has been an age since I was there. I noticed they no longer serve lengua. Afterward, I picked up somokes and a bottle of RC and rode the bus back home.

Then it was back to the novella until around 11. I finished Chapter 11. Off back to bed, the brain kept running. Like Wednesday, more bad timing.

Up this morning to do some running before the group session. Payless so that when CC comes over she has thngs to eat while she reads my work. Minnetrista for apples.

And having caught the world up on my doings, I will close out for now.


 

sch 

 

 

 

Optimizing Into Ruin

I spent too many years using computers in my old profession. They have wonderful uses, and they helped hang on as the economy receded from Anderson. I also saw Microsoft Word change its format so that all prior versions were rendered nullities. Symantec never translated a very capable DOS database to Windows, and one that I still doubt its full potential was tapped. From this background, some of my friends call me a Luddite for my doubts in all the wonders of tech.

A 1976 Buick LeSabre with its distribution cap directly behind the fan blades left me with a general distrust of engineers. They get bright ideas, implement them, and never have to deal with their practical impact.  

 I prefer empiricism to idealism.

All this leads me to recommend The efficiency trap: why optimising everything can backfire, badly (The Guardian).

The hospital bed story illustrated the first one: weakening a system’s robustness by squeezing out too much slack. An empty bed can be redundant on a quiet Tuesday night, but it’s somewhere precious to put the next patient when flu cases surge. If you judge a system by its performance under ordinary conditions, you can lose the ability to cope with extraordinarily challenging ones.

A second trap is having a too-narrow definition of “best”. Take the city of Milton Keynes. Designed by urban planners in the late 1960s, it has an American-style grid system. As the city began to be built out, roundabouts rather than traffic lights became a defining feature of its road junctions; today there are about 130 of them. The roundabouts were great for traffic flow, but they came with a now-notorious cost. Have you ever taken the coach from Oxford to Cambridge? An hour in, you get great views of Milton Keynes, but a busload of queasy passengers, as the coach negotiates one roundabout after another. Slow down, swing left, curve right, accelerate. It’s hard to appreciate the seamless merging of vehicles when your stomach is churning.

Traffic flow is important, to be sure. Engineers find it convenient to optimise because it’s relatively easy to measure. Passenger comfort, on the other hand, is harder to quantify. In a case like this, optimisation gives you the best answer to the question you asked, but can deliver unwelcome answers to questions you failed to consider.

A third trap appears when attempts to optimise collide. Even if every part of a system is acting optimally, the system as a whole may not. On 6 May 2010, US financial markets gave a dramatic demonstration of the effect. In the middle of an already falling market, the S&P 500 suddenly plunged another 5% in just five minutes. The whipsaw on the upside was even wilder; within 10 minutes, the market had recovered. Hundreds of individual securities briefly traded at absurdly low prices.

Details are in the original.

 I never heard of Ivan Illich, wish I had and I think What Is a ‘Responsibly Limited Tool’ in the Age of AI? (Los Angeles Review of Books) goes well with the preceding.   

Illich’s stature as a public intellectual was established by a sequence of pamphlet-sized books that he published in the 1970s while he was running the Centro Intercultural de Documentación (CIDOC) in Cuernavaca, outside Mexico City. CIDOC had become a magnet for students of a countercultural stripe, as well as a crossroads for thinkers from Paulo Freire to Susan Sontag. The first of these books, Deschooling Society (1971), argued that compulsory education had become institutionalized to the point of being counterproductive, a machinic system for churning out credentialed future employees rather than independent thinkers. It remains perhaps his most provocative and influential book. But it is Tools for Conviviality (1973) that offers the more wholesale and devastating critique of life in an industrialized capitalist society.

***

What is most radical in Tools for Conviviality—and also most frustrating, because it is so difficult to envisage—is the proposal that we should limit our tools. Illich rightly calls this a “taboo.” Western society, loosely called, has harnessed its concept of progress so tightly to technology that it is almost unthinkable to call for limits to be imposed on technological development without being dubbed a Luddite. Or, at least, that was the case until recently. With today’s growing nervousness about the power of AI and its rogue capacities, that taboo is being broken. Both Anthropic’s Dario Amodei and DeepMind’s Demis Hassabis have confessed that they think the AI arms race needs to be stopped. To be clear, they are not proposing that we limit AI tout court but rather acknowledging that the frenetic zero-sum game they’re playing is forcing them and their competitors to move at a pace that abandons all checks and balances for fear of falling behind. They have admitted that they’ve lost control and—incredibly, given Silicon Valley’s libertarian ideals—are begging the government to step in and slow things down. Tech commentators, meanwhile, are giving odds on the risk of human extinction.

It might be worth pausing here for a moment to consider the challenge Illich sets us when he talks about limits to tools. Even with more prosaic technologies than neural networks, achieving a static state is potentially impracticable. Digital devices are not like mechanical machines; they are mutable by definition, designed to evolve in our hands. A smartphone may feel as tangible as a slab of basalt, but this belies a shape-shifting operating system that is hell-bent on either self-improvement or what Cory Doctorow calls “enshittification.” There is no point at which you can freeze this system at some platonic ideal. At the very least, Illich’s notion that we should put a “roof” on our technical prowess would require a degree of consensus on what is enough that is difficult to imagine reaching.

***
 
The question is, in a world of billions of autonomous agents running the show, what is the value of being human? Another way of asking this is, what is the human purpose that we are being freed up for? Manual work is still very much on offer, of course, but creativity? Aren’t the tech bros at pains to prove that AI can do that too—make illustrations, compose music, write novels? Here, I think, Illich’s concept of limits, grounded as it is in the human scale and in human agency, is exposed as somewhat technocratic. It suggests that there is a technical solution through our tools, if we could muster the collective and political will. Interestingly, Pope Leo XIV’s first encyclical, Magnifica Humanitas, published earlier this year, takes a more ontological approach, arguing that it is the sanctity of human dignity that must be protected, not human capability.
 
***
... Tools were meant to be a practical place to start. Retooling may sound like a modest proposal, but in Illich’s mind, it was potentially revolutionary and involved inverting the politics of tools in our favor. As one of his most insightful interpreters, David Cayley, puts it, “The question essentially is who’s on top, the user or the tool.” 

 Can we not have some common sense, please?

sch 11/10 



Thursday, November 12, 2026

Angels, Academic Dullards, Our Lack Of Imagination

Entertaining Angels: Nolan’s Odyssey and What We Owe the Stranger (Marginalia Review of Books) is the subject of this post. This post treads on Why the dilettante is the anti-hero of our over-optimised age (Aeon Essays) that I noted in Research, Amusements & Place I've Stuck My Nose Into The Past Few Days. That is the death of curiosity, of a retreat into intellectual rigidity.

The point about curiosity is made here: 

The film is precisely this movement into a new moral key that we have failed to hear in much of the criticism that has generated around it. Writing in the London Review of Books, Emily Wilson, the celebrated translator of Homer, readily acknowledges that adaptations may acquire their greatest power through radical transformation. Nevertheless, her review takes shape as a ledger of Homeric losses. Nolan’s characters are flatter, his psychology thinner, his treatment of war, memory, time, and homecoming impoverished beside the poem’s extraordinary amplitude. Many of these observations are entirely fair: no three-hour commercial film could preserve Homer’s narrative breadth or psychological density. As an exposition of what Homer possesses and Nolan omits, Wilson’s critique is formidable. As an encounter with Nolan’s retelling, I think it is curiously incurious. The expertise that enables her to identify everything that has fallen away leaves surprisingly little space for what the film has brought into view.

Paul Losensky’s account of the Persian term taqlīd offers a striking image for understanding this relationship between the so-called original and an adaptation. Loosely translated as “imitation,” taqlīd derives from the act of fastening a collar, rope, ornament, or sword belt around another’s neck. The image gradually acquired the sense of unthinking submission: the receiver is bound to the giver and led where the giver chooses. Approached through the logic of taqlīd, the original becomes master and the adaptation its obedient dependent, valuable chiefly insofar as it follows the path prescribed for it. But retelling begins where obedience ends.

 I have a favorite Persian word now. Its meaning is grotesque and terrible and a little frightening. Photocopying beyond the point that the image disappears comes to mind. What does that do to the culture? Anemia can kill. It seems to me that cultural anemia would do the same to society. In turn, it would render its members dullards, useless to one another. 

When I was 23, I worked in a bar with bands. I heard many of our customers complain about the disco on the other side of twon and disparage bands that did not play the cover songs just like the records. This is how rock and roll died.

Being now an Orthodox Christian, the reciprocity mentioned below has importance. There is a reciprocal relationship between God and a person, and between individuals.  

The film also retrieves from the archaic world a law capable of judging such power. At the center of Nolan’s Odyssey stands the law of Zeus, the ancient code of xenia that bound host to stranger and made hospitality a measure of civilization. Nolan expands this inherited obligation into what Klein identifies as the film’s “central trick”: a Jewish and Christian ethic of reciprocity enters the Homeric world. Zeus’s protection of the wanderer begins to echo Leviticus’s injunction to love the foreigner, Hillel’s refusal to inflict upon another what one finds hateful, and the Gospel’s command to treat others as one wishes to be treated. The stranger’s claim no longer depends upon kinship, usefulness, or likeness. It interrupts the moral enclosure by which a person or a nation makes its own suffering absolute.

This is a morality that has been missing from our politics. The dehumanizing of wide swathes of people by those in power - here and elsewhere - has come easily when the powerful instill fear in their electorates. I put this in here because such a politics demeans all of us.

Returning to ciriticism and the rigidity of critical imaginations, I leave you with this: 

Why, then, has criticism around the movie proved so much more adept at cataloguing Nolan’s departures than at describing this crucial intervention? Rita Felski has observed that the affective range of academic criticism remains remarkably narrow: exquisitely articulate in its adversarial modes and excruciatingly tongue-tied before the work that art performs upon its audiences. Wilson’s review exemplifies this limitation. Its erudition illuminates Homer, yet it leaves little room for the possibility that the film has perceived something urgent in the epic and made it newly visible. Criticism adequate to retelling needs two forms of attention: precision about what transformation leaves behind, and receptivity to what it releases. The first preserves the density of the old work. The second recognizes why an old story has returned now.

To borrow a phrase from Jerry Lee Lews: think about it. 

The full essay reflects the movie that I saw. 

sch 11/10 

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

The CIA,Why Write #1033, Characters, Podcasts And Colson Whitehead

 A Table for Fortune by William T Vollmann review – a hugely ambitious 3,000-page portrait of America’s decline (The Guardian) tells America's recent history through the CIA.

Why Do We Sing? by Lauren Elkin (Literary Hub).

In the years since I left the theatre, I have often thought that I chose writing instead of music because among trained singers, everyone sounds good, and one good voice is not often much different from another; rare are performers who are so unique that they are irreplaceable. Increasingly so: it seems that most of the women you hear on Broadway today have, with few exceptions, interchangeable voices. Some time during college I discovered the joy of the blank page, where I could say whatever I wanted, however I wanted to say it, and where there was such freedom that in the end there was no competition, writing took me as I was and didn’t ask for there to be any less of me. I could be judged not only on sound or on form, but on content. Whereas in music, I could only ever be as good as everyone else. I went quiet.  

Here's the Secret to Believable Character Arcs: Change Is an Awakening (Helping Writers Become Authors).

This one has me thinking the most: 

We all know about beginning our stories with a Characteristic Moment that introduces our character to readers. This moment is supposed to illustrate our characters’ starting point within the story. As such, we often want to create a Characteristic Moment that illustrates characters’ initial enslavement to the Lie.

But that’s not quite enough. We also have to make sure we’re illustrating characters’ latent understanding of and desire for the Truth. Sometimes we can do this simultaneously in the same Characteristic Moment; sometimes we need two separate scenes to illustrate both sides of this character.

Other points made: Reveal the Truth Gradually Through the Plot, Give Characters Convincing Reasons to Resist the Truth, Give Characters Strong Reasons to Pursue the Truth, and Make Character Transformation an Awakening. I hope to finish the novella that has been occupying my time these past two weeks on Thursday and to start revising this weekend. I want to keep these in mind as they have application. I am sure they apply to “Love Stinks”, if ever I get back to that.

I have not had time yet to explore this but I still offer to whoever reads these posts: Podcasts Archives - PodCastle.


 

 sch 11/10

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Life These Few Days Previosuly Not Mentioned.

Thursday was the dentist, the bank, and back to the apartment for a nap and some writing.

Fall in Muncie: 




Friday was the group session, grocery shopping, and back to do some reading of emails. I did some work on the novella. When I got home, the belt buckle broke. 

Saturday, I got out the Gorilla glue and tried to fix the belt. Not that I went very far even when I thought it was fixed. So, I used my time writing.

Sunday was Liturgy, an over-long nap, and a walk down to the laundromat with a bag of laundry. Someone had all the washers tied up. I went over to the convenience store and found out my debit card had been left at my apartment. I walked back to the apartment, back to the convenience store and returned to the laundromat. The same person still monopolized the washers. I had been gone for maybe 20 minutes, and the person had not returned to remove their laundry to dryers. I went outside, read a little about J.M. Synge, and smoked two cigarettes. Then I spotted an open washer. I had put in my laundry and dropped $1.25 into the machine when I saw it was a $6.50 machine. I budget five dollars for my laundry. Out came my laundry and I waited a bit longer. It all worked out after about another 30 minutes. I went back out to my book and smokes. Only when I sat down, my belt buckle broke again. Not being able to be fully mobile, I called J and KH. It was a long walk home with my laundry in one hand and the other hand keeping up pants. This is what my luck looks like.

I started Black Doves on Netflix. I find it a rather good spy story. 

Monday, I meant to do some running. All I did was get to Walmart for a new belt. I bought a couple of items from the grocery, too.

I went to Vespers. An idea came to me that led to a piece I want to put into my novella. So, I did a bit of writing last night, just some dialog. 

I woke up on Tuesday and what am I thinking about? My novella. Some parts of Tuesday I have already written about today.

I calculated I could have the thing done by the end of the week. That I could get started this afternoon. Then I looked at the calendar. Instead of seeing the eye doctor was for this morning, it was this afternoon. Okay, I can start after I get back from the doctor. And I have to readjust my schedule. Off to the insurance agent and the grocery this morning before the appointment rather than after. Oh, well. 

Instead of the novella and the insurance agent, I worked on a few blog posts. I still need to get at my Friday session notes. 

I submitted “The First Day of Feeling Free” to Split Lip Magazine. 

The eye doctor gave me good news about my glaucoma; it seems to have abated. I may celebrate tomorrow. 

Going through a few other items in my tabs: 

Parker Posey Talks with Michael Schulman (The New Yorker)! I think Parker Posey is an amazing actress - never quite what she will do with a character, so you have to keep your eye on her. The video does a grand job of showing what makes her special. How much do I like her? We watched the Netflix Lost in Space while I was in prison. I kept hoping the Robinson family would die and she take center stage in the show.

Wondering at Philosophy With Kafka’s Dog (The MIT Press Reader) left me thinking I have nto read enough Kafka.

In your book “How to Research Like a Dog: Kafka’s New Science,” the connection between you as a philosopher and Kafka as a storyteller-philosopher is significant. You highlight the deep intersection between your philosophical outlook and Kafka’s narrative world. Because Kafka chose fiction to express his ideas, have you ever wondered what his philosophy would look like if liberated from storytelling? Have you ever wished he had written formal philosophical treatises instead?

No. Kafka comes closest to such pure philosophical writing in his Zürau aphorisms. There you can find propositions that are akin to the conceptual abstraction usually associated with philosophical thought. But my point in writing my book on Kafka’s philosopher dog was not to lament that Kafka is a failed philosopher, or that he should have written a philosophical treatise instead of a story. Instead, I wanted to appreciate what he did produce, and to extend it in a new way.

The story “Investigations of a Dog” is a wonderful parable of philosophy, and reading it can shake up our ideas about philosophy and help us appreciate the strangeness of its practice — especially given its current state of academicization. Philosophy begins in wonder, as the often-repeated line goes; what Kafka’s story allows us to do is to wonder at philosophy. Philosophy becomes an object of wonder for itself.

Now, the problem of the relationship between philosophy and literature is in fact an ancient one. It goes back to Plato, who had a real literary flair, composing not straightforward treatises but playful dialogues, and employing myths at crucial points. Maybe more than anything else, it’s these myths that have had a profound and enduring impact. In the book, I invite us to read Kafka’s myths like the Platonic myths, but for the Freudian age. Instead of the allegory of the cave, Kafka gives us the burrow (as Mladen Dolar has argued in his great essay on “The Burrow”); instead of the myth of the origins of the human being and the cosmos, Kafka gives us Odradek (Jean-Claude Milner writes brilliantly about this). And, instead of the myth of Er, the myth about the transmigration of souls choosing their next lives, we have Kafka’s prenatal hesitancy, expressed in his stunning line: “My life is a hesitation before birth.” That’s how I read Kafka, as a creator of new philosophical myths, or a new mythology of reason.

 ***

First, about nihilism: it’s clear that, for the characters themselves, this is not a problem. None of them thinks that “nothing matters.” On the contrary, they are totally obsessed with their different quests and pursuits! They follow them to the bitter end. When things go badly for him, does the hunger artist complain that fasting is stupid and meaningless? Just the opposite: he dreams of a fast breaking all records, and in a way, he disappears into this dream. Nothing is more foreign to a Kafkian protagonist than giving up in despair. On the other hand, this is a running joke throughout the fictions: why not “give it up” (the title of one of Kafka’s stories)? Sometimes there are friends or onlookers that marvel at the main character’s incapacity to just walk away from his troubles. Although it might look like they are being oppressed by external forces and inscrutable systems of power, on a certain level, they do it to themselves. Kafka’s characters “freely” encage themselves.

***

Let me raise a more general question: Where do individuals meet society? I would say, it’s not simply in their formation, education, or socialization, their Bildung. Becoming a subject is not only a process of internalizing rules, customs, ideologies, and habits — what’s called the social construction of the self, or the process of ideological interpellation. Rather, where this meeting really takes place is at those points where socialization fails, as it inevitably does. Not only because the individual is unruly and rebellious (which is true), but also, and above all, because the rules, norms, and teachings of society are contradictory, ambiguous, and riddled with gaps. A crisis in the life of the individual meets a hole in the symbolic order of society: It’s at these neuralgic points that the real encounter between self and community takes place. You could conceive of it as a kind of borderland, the “borderland between loneliness and community” (Kafka’s phrase). Here the individual is forced to be inventive, to create its own ad hoc solutions to its problems, in the margins of history, culture, language, and the normative solutions that society prescribes. You could also call this the borderland between psychology and sociology, their failed intersection. That is where the unconscious lies. 

Good night and good luck. 

 sch

 

 

 

Tuesday - Trending Up?

I did not make it to the insurance agent today. I did  get to Payless in the morning for a few things I wanted to fix for lunch and items I had not bought at Walmart. Then was a stop at Ball State's Daily News. The big thing was the eye doctor. The glaucoma has abated.

The front room's reorganization started today.

A trip down to the convenience store after dinner.

I have been listening to The Pretty Things over the past few days. They are famous for being one of the British invasion bands who never made it here. I am a little surprised. No more than a little. They are what The Yardbirds might have been with a better singer and definitely what they might have been with better songs. In the line of The Rolling Stones, but not so macrabre. Speaking of The Stones, this is playing right now:

 

Interesting take, far less poppy than the original (which is one of my favorite Stones songs.)

Yesterday another rejection for “First Day of Feeling Free”:

Thank you for sharing this work with The Adroit Journal, and thank you for your patience as we consider and discuss submissions. We hope this note finds you well.

After a review of your submission, the staff has unfortunately decided that this submission is not right for us. Best of luck placing this work elsewhere, and thanks again!

Sincerely,

The Editors

The Adroit Journal

www.theadroitjournal.org

Some amusements;

The 100 Best Indie Rock Albums of All Time (Pitchfork) (because I actually know a few of them!)

It's a Wonderful Life - Muncie Civic Theatre 

I plan on doing the mail, a couple of more posts and then call it a night.

Tomorrow, back to my fiction. 


 

sch 


 

Monday, November 9, 2026

Today, So Far (Plus Pieces on Writing)

 If the weekend was one debacle after another, today has been a whimpering, lamed progress towards not much.

I went to Walmart first thing this morning to buy a new belt. When I got back here, I lost all energy and fell asleep until almost 11 AM.

I got through some of my emal. There were two other posts finished. The bedroom and kitchen tidied. Then I wrapped up this one. I want to get  to Vespers, so that is all for now.

Storytelling: Writing Chapters and Scenes (Writing Forward)

Each scene is a miniature story within the story and has a beginning, middle, and end. A scene opens, there’s conflict, and then the scene closes. At the scene level, conflict is usually minor; the larger story conflict is spread throughout the entire story.

Some storytellers say that each scene should contain an emotional transition, which can help build tension into a scene and gives the story emotional flow. If a scene starts on a positive note (the protagonist is happy), then it can end on a negative note (the protagonist is sad). These emotional or tonal shifts don’t need to be intense or dramatic. Something as simple as showing a clumsy character spilling wine all over his white shirt can give a scene a downward emotional shift.

However, these emotional shifts are not required—and in fact, they’re not always possible. Some stories require a series of scenes that maintain a constant tone without significant emotional shifts.

The core function of any scene is to move the story forward with plot and character development. The more development a scene contains, the richer it becomes. One scene can move the plot forward while another scene develops the protagonist, but if the plot and character development can be contained within a single scene (rather than two separate scenes), then that scene will be more powerful.

Nathaniel Hawthorne’s notebooks reveal the strange workings of his imagination

Hawthorne’s notebook fragments are wide-ranging, but certain themes repeatedly crop up: the psychology of divided selves, tensions between men and women and even possibilities for a better world. As he hopefully imagines in a stand-alone fragment: “Cannon transformed to church-bells.”

Who was Hawthorne the writer? A neo-Puritan moralist? A social realist? A modernist? A romancer? The fragments complicate rather than answer such questions. In his preface to “The Scarlet Letter,” Hawthorne remarks on his desire to “keep the inmost Me behind its veil.”

But with the help of the fragments, we get behind the veil, at least a bit – and glimpse something like what Sophia believed was the spirit informing Hawthorne’s writing.

Weekly Readings #247 (11/03/26-11/08/26) - by John Pistelli

... There is no one book you can read to make you a great writer if you don’t otherwise have it in you to be one and no one book whose omission will doom you if you do have it in you. Both anti-intellectualism and an idolatry or fetishization of mere bookishness4 can mislead an author. Modernism, for example, bore witness to both tendencies: Lawrence at his worst over-valuing blood and instinct while Pound sank his poetry under trivia he thought the key to history. I got to certain books late in life myself. I don't think I read the Aeneid—and even then only in translation—until I was 30, a more foundational text (until its displacement by the full recovery of Homer) it’s hardly possible to imagine. You should read the most obvious classics that still have currency sooner rather than later. If you’re reading this but haven’t read Hamlet, please stop reading this right now and go read Hamlet. In response to a similar question earlier this year, I noted that the core works of the western canon, everything before the explosion of print culture in modernity, are a fairly small and manageable set: the Bible, Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey, the major Greek tragedies (the Oresteia, the Theban plays, Medea and Bacchae) and Platonic dialogues (the Apology, Symposium, Republic), Ovid’s Metamorphoses and Virgil’s Aeneid, Dante’s Divine Comedy, Cervantes’s Don Quixote, the major plays of Shakespeare (A Midsummer Night’s Dream, As You Like It, Hamlet, King Lear, Othello, Macbeth, The Tempest), Milton’s Paradise Lost. But you don’t need to read all of those before you write a novel. The “western canon,” which is essentially a 20th-century construct (cf. Naomi on “Great Books”), was not always equally available to all the great writers. Dante did not read Homer; Shakespeare did not read Homer or Dante. As Ian Watt long ago pointed out in The Rise of the Novel, many of the early major novelists, like Defoe and Richardson, were in fact marked by their non-elite non-education in the Greek and Roman classics, which they either didn’t read at all or read in translation, as we tend to do. I did hate the way the rival identity politics of the last decade and a half dismissed so many still good and still relevant classics, the English canon of poetry and novels, Shakespeare and Jane Austen, because the one side regarded them as white imperial oppressors and the other side as effete relics for the liberal elite. When I wrote this a few years ago, people responded as if I’d meant to criticize “the woke”—and I don’t have a lot of patience for left-wing canon-smashing when a left-wing defense of the canon as extending high culture to all is the more obvious and (if I may) dialectical position—but I actually had in mind some of the more literalist exponents of “men’s literature” who often establish their bona fides by going on podcasts and saying they don’t read such gay stuff as Austen or George Eliot.5 To return to your question, though, let me cite the aforementioned Pound in one of his sounder judgments from ABC of Reading, a book I’ve carried around with me since high school despite my generally not being a Poundian: “Great literature is simply language charged with meaning to the utmost possible degree,” his enlargement of the equation he chanced upon in a German-to-Italian dictionary, “Dichten = Condensare.” The prerequisite to serious writing, then, is not reading this or that particular work, but a period of immersion in—serious contemplation of—some number of the greatest works where language is so charged, both to study consciously how this energizing can be accomplished as a matter of method and to incorporate unconsciously the experience or what I have elsewhere called the music of such intensive energetics....

Think about this because I am thinking about this, something I have been known to do much of:

... One final piece of advice though: read poetry no matter what you intend to write. Poetry is the base or basis of all literature, its taproot into the vaster reservoirs of orature, of music, of dance, as well as the form in which language is always maximally charged. We read prose sentenced by sentence, sometimes even paragraph by paragraph or chapter by chapter, but poetry word by word.

sch