Showing posts with label Theater. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Theater. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 4, 2026

Reporting On Submission, Books & Writing Stuff (A Sequel of Sorts)

Stumbling through the remainder of Sunday night; here are the results. 

Submissions today.

Fusion Fragment,  The Georgia Review, The Adroit Journal, and Epiphany were sent The First Day of Feeling Free.

Haven Spec Magazine - “The Psychotic Ape”

The Four Way Books, Driftwood Press  "Plain Tales From The Flatlands” 

Books, stories, and the like 

Come Morning (The Dilettante) I found to be an enticing piece of flash fiction.

Speeding through the streets until your soles burned, you tightened a grip on the suitcase clattering behind you with your whole life on its rollers. One wheel hadn’t been quite right since knocking against a curb several blocks back, and your heart lurched at each ill-timed pop and scrape. It would make sense to turn back now. The place you left barely qualified as a shoe closet, but it had someone to share the bed with each night, to need and be needed by, to plead and prove yourself to—which was almost like love. 

Hemingway’s lost generation turns 100 (Engelsberg ideas) takes on my second least favorite Hemingway novel (To Have and To Have Not gets that prize). I have been uncomfortable with The Sun Also Rises since I was an idiot Freshman at Ball State University. No doubt it has power but its characters are such a bunch of creeps.

For a new reader picking up Sun  now, it is hard to comprehend how groundbreaking it was in 1926. By now we are used to Hemingway’s prose; his style has been imitated, copied and parodied for a century. His books have become a prop for the tortured, monosyllabic male in mainstream culture (even Jess Mariano in Gilmore Girls is depicted as a fan) – but when it was released, it was radical.

The sentences are stripped almost bare. Short, factual sentences. Dialogue that sounds like a pared-down screenplay: people talking as people actually do, most of the meaning left unsaid, very little spoon-fed to the reader (except, memorably, a slightly condescending explanation of what the drink Pernod is). There are transcripts of drunken conversations with next to no explanation or ornamentation added, and bald descriptions of places that still manage to make them unfold, powerfully, before your eyes, whether it be the central square of Pamplona, a bus climbing the mountains of the Basque Country, or a train rammed with pilgrims who have taken over the lunch car. No superfluous adjectives clutter the images, and they resonate more strongly as a result. The novel was an instant hit.

Sun was never without controversy. It ruined several lives, or at least reputations. Hemingway gave his friends flimsy pseudonyms that echoed the syllables and rhythms of their real names and did little to conceal their identities. Lady Brett Ashley – the novel’s anti-heroine – was based on Lady Duff Twysden, a twice-married English socialite with whom Hemingway was infatuated. Brett’s lover, Mike Campbell, was Duff’s real-life lover, Pat Guthrie. The Jewish American novelist Robert Cohn was based on the Jewish American novelist Harold Loeb, who really had run off to the coast with Duff for an intense but short-lived tryst. The writer Don Stewart, who served partly as inspiration for the character Bill Gorton, said the novel was pure journalism.

The portraits were not flattering. Hemingway depicted his friends warts and all, then added a few fictional warts for good measure. Some of the most damaging incidents – Cohn cracking under pressure and punching Jake, or Brett seducing a teenage bullfighter – were inventions. But crowded in alongside so much that was factually true, the distinction was easy to miss. To add insult to injury, the novel that parodied his writer friends outsold anything they produced themselves. It must have rankled all the more when Hemingway took the Nobel Prize for Literature in 1954.

The Guardian view on Caryl Churchill’s Triumph: a play for today (The Guardian) is here because I read a pair of Churchill's plays in prison and thought he was more than worthwhile keeping an eye on for all that I had never heard of her. She is English, so is my ignorance an American thing?

The Guardian’s Michael Billington called Churchill “theatre’s great disruptor”. With Triumph she is disrupting the conventions of theatregoing itself: a play isn’t always something to be enjoyed between an early supper, interval drinks and the last train home. She has turned the attention economy on its head. Like a Covid-era emergency press conference, Triumph interrupts its audience’s day to make them listen. It jolts us out of our complacency.

October '26 Statistics for the Submission Pit

  “Family Lore,” by Téa Obreht (The New Yorker) is probably behind a paywall, so I quoted the paragraph below to give a taste of Obreht's style. The story involves a husband trying to do the right thing, a dog, a possible rabid bat, and a new-born baby. It is a comedy-horror of brilliance. Obreht does not publish like Joyce Carol Oates, but is always worth reading when she does.

When the dog was finally in his arms, his whole body pulsing with the force of his heartbeats, the husband sank his face into the dog’s musty neck and let himself be still. There was so much to lose, and so many different ways to lose it. 

‎The New Yorker: Fiction - Podcast - Apple Podcasts 

Science fiction writer John Scalzi discusses his novel 'Monsters of Ohio' 

Paris Review:  Kazuo Ishiguro, The Art of Fiction No. 196 

Writing articles

Grammar Rules: Ending a Sentence with a Preposition (Writing Forward) starts with my own opinion and ends with something we all ought to keep in mind.

A longstanding grammar myth says we’re not supposed to end a sentence with a preposition. For years, this myth has persisted, tying writers up in knots and making their heads spin around sentences that simply must end with a preposition.

For example: Which store are you going to?

Folks who were taught (and are now attached to the idea) that one should never end a sentence with a preposition will argue that the proper way to write the sentence is as follows: To which store are you going?

But nobody talks that way.

***

The issue with ending a sentence with a preposition is more a matter of style or rhetoric than grammar. If you want proof, check out this list of references on ending a sentence with a preposition.

So go forth and end sentences with prepositions, but only when it makes sense to do so. Write your sentences to be clear and concise, and you’ll be fine. Keep writing!

I have both doubts and a curiosity about Hemingway Editor. It uses AI, so a mark against it there. I am already finding enough errors with grammar and spell checkers that do not tout their AI roots. OTOH, it might be interesting to see if it produces anything different.

But more importantly, what if one's style is more Faulkner or Jose Saramago than Hemingway?

Writing a Novel in Short Stories by Luis Vocem is here out of my vanity. “Plain Tales from the Flatlands” came from a collection of short stories that interested no one individually or as a collection. They were interrelated but did not run along a plot. I sliced and diced the stories so that they were more connected, to even have a ghost of a plot, and came up with a novella. This short essay let me know I was not completely mad. Perhaps it will do the same for you.

The one thing a short story must do is stand on its own, period. Whether it is the plot of a larger story in something else you’re working on, or minor events around a character, it has to complete its own dramatic arc.

The cycle of creation, editing, rejection, and publishing can take anywhere from two weeks to a year or more. You can be working on one, two, or even half a dozen stories at a time. At some point, you know whether the story needs a major revision or to be put out to pasture. What is most important, however, is not really the story, but YOUR learning process ­– taking chances, developing your own voice. Fail, learn, learn, learn, revise, revise, revise, improve, improve, improve. There’s so much you can learn. In the short story, it all happens quickly – a luxury you do not have in the novel. 

This approach may appear to be more difficult than writing a chapter, but it’s not. Instead, it gives you clarity about the material: Does it have a dramatic arc? What is the realization? Does it stand on its own? What better way to test if the material is good than sending it out and see if literary magazines want to publish it?

For me, the novel-in-short-stories was not a conscious decision. It evolved. One story got published. I could not get one of the characters out of my mind. Then another story related to that character flooded my consciousness. Wrote it. Sent it out, got published. On to the next.

sch 11/1

 

 

  

  

 

Thursday, October 8, 2026

Indianapolis Theatricals

 Indianapolis has a theater scene which includes New Plays Indy — The New Harmony Project. Now, if I could find a way to see some of it. It looks like local talent is also writing plays that are produced. 

Meet six historical reenactors bringing Indiana history to life.

Shareef played one of the first characters for Freetown Village, a history museum that tours around the state. It was founded by Ophelia Wellington in 1982.

He played Isaiah Cuffee, a barber from the year 1870 in Indianapolis. Wellington developed the character using U.S. Census records and books. Wellington remembers Shareef shaking on stage at first, but bringing the character to life, whom she said he emulated, anyway.

From there, Freetown created other composite characters, including teachers, ministers and attorneys.

***

Elaine Sholty was introduced to the living history scene in the early 1990s. She and her husband were leaving a movie theater after catching “Gettysburg,” featuring Richard Jordan and Martin Sheen. On the way out, they passed a group of Civil War reenactors with a canon prop.

The couple began doing reenactments together as a hobby. Sholty portrayed northern and southern women of the Civil War era in her mid-century day dresses — at places such as Crown Hill Cemetery. At a gun salute, she met members of Daughters of the American Revolution, where she is now the Indianapolis chapter president.

***

Most elementary school students on field trips to Conner Prairie come into contact with historical interpreters. Interpretation coordinator Anne Coffey plans all programming on the historic grounds at the museum in Fishers. She also plays a few characters such as Mrs. Whitaker. Mrs. Whitaker is loud and outgoing, and her husband owns a general store set in 1836.

Coffey said all of the characters in Prairie Town are composite characters, meaning they’re not based on one real person, but a mix of facts and of perspectives of people who lived in Hamilton County during the 1830s.

***

Actors Donnice Robinson and Tracey Wynn met in 2019 while working as characters in the Madam C.J. Walker exhibit at the Indiana Historical Society. Wynn played Madam C.J. Walker, and Robinson portrayed Candace Pinkston, who was one of Walker’s sales agents.

When the exhibit closed, the duo didn’t want to see “those people go to sleep.” In 2022, they founded Soulful Journeys of Women. The company has a contract with the Indianapolis Public Library to perform History on Stage.

***

Tristan Ross has always been a “history dork.” Even his email address calls on the Danish astronomer Tycho Brahe known for making the most accurate astronomical observations before the invention of the telescope. He described his previous role as an interpreter and facilitator at the Indiana Historical Society for eight years as “a spoonful of sugar that helped the lesson go down.”

“For the past decades, the humanities have been an academic punching bag ever since STEM became a hot button thing. There is a lot of wisdom to be gleaned from what has happened in the past,” he said.

 

 

 

 

   

Saturday, October 3, 2026

Friday, October 2, 2026

Edgar Allan Poe, Harlan Ellison, Hamlet, and Marcel Proust All Walk Into A Bar.....

 


 


 

and in the bar they discuss American Transcendentalism.


 

sch 9/29

Wednesday, September 23, 2026

Writing, Plays and Books: Hemingway, Salman Rushdie, Lolita, Dorthy L. Sayers

 Rereading “The Odyssey”:  Translations and the Film (Thornfield Hall)

Every decade there is a popular new translation. In the 1970s and ’80s, it would have been Richmond Lattimore’s, with its pared-down style, then considered closest to the Greek.  And Robert Fagles’  gorgeous, lively translation, published in 1996,  outdid Lattimore’s in beauty of language and poetic style.   And now there is Daniel Mendelsohn’s new translation, published last year, which was praised by Jorie Graham and Lee Child.

Of course seeing  the film of The Odyssey  – twice –  has inspired me to reread the epic poem (Fagles’ translation).  Before I make a few comments about Book 22, let  me talk about the cast of the movie.

Short, to the point, and a post I agree with in the most part. I have not read The Odyssey since the movie came out, but i do not recall it leaving me tired. 

I like how this documentary points out the difference between Hemingway as a man, a writer, and a myth.

 


Christina Anderson: “Man In Love” (The Yale Review), I have draft plays I need to get back to, but they worry me since I know so little about stage craft. Ms. Anderson annotates her play. I like the play. Her annotations give me ideas.

More Hemingway! I was disappointed by For Whom The Bells Toll when I read it again in my fifites. This podcast almost restored it for me. 

 
Another play excerpted in The Yale Review, S. Shakthidharan: “The Sun’s Song”.
The Sun’s Song, by contrast, has an all-male-identifying cast and consists of several acts and intervals. It alternates time periods and takes place across many different parts of the globe. It is the story of a father and a son, and it delves into questions of masculinity and intimacy; the wild earth and the wild in us; the politics of climate change; and the consequences of not dealing with your own hurt. I hope it will premiere in 2028, although it is still very much a work in progress. I am sharing an excerpt of the current draft below, along with annotations to provide insight into the play and my artistic decisions. 
Again, I learned from the excerpts.
 
Not sure if I ever posted this style analysis of Hemingway and feeling too lazy to check myself.


 
 I am not sure why Jonathan Frazen gets on my nerves. That he is about my age and from the Midwest and can damn well write, I ought to be less cautious about him. It goes back to The Corrections and a sense that he treated Midwesterners as bumpkins. That he's way smarter than I ever could have been might be in there anyway. All the same I read what I can about and by him, such as The Guardian's profile piece Jonathan Franzen: ‘It’s still mysterious to me that I was angry for so long’. 

Does this mean he sees writing as a means of self-improvement? God, no! When he’s working on a scene, trying to capture a character or get the tone right, he’s not thinking in moral terms. “If you’re really engaged with that, it’s not a matter of morality, but a matter of getting at something true. So I prefer truth as a goal to morality, to self-improvement, to the betterment of one’s soul,” he says. “I don’t really care about bettering my soul. I care about getting it right,” he adds. And then, the reflexive edit: “Which is a pretty good ending line.” 

A review of Library of America's Nineteenth Century short stories:

 


I know why I like Toni Morrison, another Midwesterner. She looks at America without blinking, without any sense of picking easy targets. Reading Tracing Shadows from Lapham’s Quarterly reinforces my bias.

That said, to pretend that just because an author was not racist, their character’s point of view or diction is not racial would be just as much of a folly. In American literary criticism up to that point, Morrison reflected, “the habit of ignoring race is understood to be a graceful, even generous, liberal gesture. To notice is to recognize an already discredited difference...Every well-bred instinct argues against noticing and forecloses adult discourse.” In other words, when it comes to the way race works in literature, denial and finger-pointing are equally childish.

Morrison’s posture was instead to treat race and racism as worthy of interest, but unworthy of debate. Eschewing the representation game of bewailing the absence or distorted presence of race in American literature, she told us: Look again! No need to destroy the canon. No need to deify it, either. Why not just read it? This begins with something as simple as the act of noticing.

 But I have spent too much time with Indiana's history of racism.

Morrison’s reading of Moby Dick spilled beyond “Unspeakable Things, Unspoken.” In a 1990 interview about her argument, the journalist Bill Moyers declared to her, of the bestselling books on the eve of the Civil War: “Your people never show up in the novels of that time.” Morrison gently contested this, saying, “Well, they do. They show up...It’s in Melville, it’s everywhere in Poe.” These are aesthetic figures rather than three-dimensional characters: “getting a truly complex human black person in a book in this country in the nineteenth century was unlikely. Melville came probably very close with…classic complexities, but not real flesh-and-blood people.” 

She raised a pattern in Moby Dick as an example of this complex symbolism: “He gets into bed with him in the very first scene. Ishmael goes to bed with Queequeg. Each one of those white people in Moby Dick has a black brother. They’re paired together. Fedallah is the shadow of Ahab. Queequeg is the shadow of Ishmael. They all have them, and they work together in tandem.” She explained that, “even though the realistic representation is not there, the information, subtextual information…is all self-reflexive, it’s all about the fabrication of a white male American.” This is one meaning of her title, which also appears as an uncanny refrain in her 1987 novel Beloved: “Unspeakable things unspoken. Always we are defining ourselves by the other.”  

No kidding. My research project has brought home to me that liberty exists only in opposition to tyranny, including slavery. That it has no definition other than as dialectic.

In her brief analysis of Huckleberry Finn in Playing in the Dark, she castigates the way critics of Twain’s 1884 novel had thus far tended to “focus on its celebration of savvy innocence, at the same time voicing polite embarrassment over the symptomatic racial attitude it enforces.” Morrison, by contrast, never dismisses or defends the racism in that novel in her writings on it. Instead, she considers its aesthetic and ideological function—and its narrative one: “Neither Huck nor Mark Twain can tolerate, in imaginative terms, Jim freed...freedom has no meaning to Huck or to the text without the specter of enslavement.” 

Lolita has never rested easily with me, a brilliantly written novel about characters I do not like, but the following has me seeing more that might make me more sympathethetic.


 There is now a documentary about Salman Rushdie being almost killed. I offer you two reviews.

‘The damage was much worse than I had imagined’: the shocking inside story of Salman Rushdie’s survival (The Guardian)

It is hard to say which time zone of the film is more viscerally shocking: the grisly footage of Rushdie being stitched and stapled back together in 2022, or the murderous hatred that roars out from news headlines in the months and years following the fatwa. In the US, the office of the Riverdale Press newspaper is firebombed after it runs an editorial about the book defending free expression; in Pakistan, six people are killed in riots; in Japan, a translator is stabbed to death; in Italy, another translator is stabbed in his home, while, in London, an effigy of a mutilated Rushdie is paraded through the streets by a furious crowd, some of whom declare on camera that nothing less than hanging will satisfy them 

Knife review: Salman Rushdie doc is a potent reminder of art's power amid persecution (Robertebert.com)

This is a simple but strong document about the importance of art as a way to comment on the world, the artist’s resilience in the face of the controversies their work might inspire, and the determination not to let violence be the answer to everything. These may seem like obvious concepts, but as this film clearly shows, we need constant reminders. 

For something a little lighter, two videos about Dorthy L. Sayers. I think there is a bit of an oversell of her as neglected but then I am one of her fans.


The Maine Review

sch 9/20

 

 

 

 

 

 

Friday, September 18, 2026

Writer Related Items

Things put off as I worked through my research project. 

A Scottish hospital. A dying man. A fascist doctor. Will we listen? (The Herald)

We know how the story starts: on a bright cold day in April as the clocks are striking 13. We know how the story ends: in the basement of the ministry of love with a cage full of starving rats. And we probably feel like we know what the story means, what it’s saying, what it’s warning us about. Yet here we are, the story is happening again, and in a different way: in a hospital in Scotland, with a dying man, and a fascist doctor. It is unexpected.

I wonder, as it gets going, this brand new version, if it can have anything left to say, or at least anything surprising. Everyone has read the book, and everyone’s familiar with its dark and disturbing iconography: Big Brother, Room 101, the Thought Police. These are the phrases we use to talk about the state we’re in. They form the questions we ask. Has fiction become fact? In what ways is 2026 like 1984? How Orwellian are we really?

***

The solutions to all of this are harder to come up with – at one point, the Scottish doctor wonders what the way forward might be and Orwell shrugs and says “I don’t know” before coughing up more blood into his handkerchief. In a way, it’s the bleakest, most dystopian way to end a bleak and dystopian story, but the comfort for us, in the audience, is that, even though the parallels are there and they’re strong, Winston’s world is much, much worse than ours, which means there’s much more hope in our world too. It’s hard to watch at times, but perhaps this version of Orwell can remind us of the basics, the sums that make us. Such as two plus two equals four. And Winston’s final desperate statement of an un-disputable, un-editable fact: it takes two to be human.    

  10 Reasons Why We Didn't Accept Your Submission (Thin Skin) - read this and it might help you revise.

From Literary Hub: What Weimar Berlin’s Most Famous Plays Revealed About Artistic Freedom and What Latin American Literature Can Teach the Current Leaders of Latin America. The latter has more humor than the former, but both should widen your horizons.

A good refresher covering everything:  All about perspectives in novels  (Nathan Bransford)

Q: Can stories with unsavory characters find a home in today’s lit mag landscape?

Processing: How Nicholas Russell Wrote Observer

Asking Confidently and Advocating for Your Work

That can feel pushy at first. Self-centered. Why should someone want to read my writing? Answering this question is key to seeking your audience’s attention. No matter who you’re speaking to, let whomever is considering your work know quickly that your writing is worth their time. And tell them why, succinctly. In my experience, when I can confidently advocate for myself and my work, the reader—agent or editor—will be more willing to entertain the possibility that it IS worth their time.  

We Were the Mulvaneys  JCO writes about her novel.

Finally, I have to say of We Were the Mulvaneys that it’s the novel closest to my heart. Passages were transcribed in white heat, as in a fevered dream. I was scarcely inventing or imagining, only just “remembering.” My writing is so much about homesickness. The rural landscapes and waterways of upstate New York, where I was born and grew up on a small, not-very-prosperous farm north of Lockport. The sights, smells and texture of life in a small town. The intense emotions of high school life, ephemeral anxieties and joys. The wounds that can cut deep, and scar for years, or a lifetime. 

 Novelist Annie Dillard has died (NPR).

I read Annie Dillard's Pilgrim at Tinker Creek while in prison. I thought it was wonderful and recommend it as being along the lines of a modern Walden.

Margaret Atwood: ‘God made the middle finger for a reason’ (London Times) - always witty, always worth listening to. 

“They don’t want Democrats being elected.” Wry insouciance vanishes, and raw exasperation with Americans enters her tone. “Yeah, so how about voting this time, instead of doing what you did with Hillary Clinton, because she wasn’t perfect enough? And how far did that get you, nincompoops?”

Atwood has no time for ideological purity or extremism on either left or right. “Defund the police was a really stupid idea,” she says. “An awful slogan. What did they think was going to replace it?” To many fans’ disappointment she won’t even call herself a feminist “because there’s too many different kinds, so what are we talking about?” I suspect she is bored with being asked about gender politics, and when I say so she looks relieved.

“I’m the human rights generation. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights was made up for a very good reason, so that’s my point of reference. And if you want rights for women, you also have to have human rights for men.” She fixes a stare. “Radical idea, right? But it doesn’t make any sense otherwise. So what kind of gender politics am I interested in? I’m interested in the legal kind. I’m interested in whether or not you can have a credit card. Or whether or not you can have an abortion, or whether or not you can wear trousers to the office.”

***

Research suggests that people are having a lot less sex, I tell her. Last year, for example, a study by the Institute for Family Studies found that weekly sex between Americans aged 18-64 fell from 55 per cent in 1990 to 37 per cent in 2024. The number of 18 to 24-year-olds who’d had no sex at all in the previous year had doubled since 2010.

“That’s interesting. Well, silly old them. Enjoy it while you can, kids.”

She pauses, then volunteers languidly: “I still get letters from pervy people. Which I’m considering rather flattering, actually, at my age. And no, I am not going to put on black leather and high heels and walk all over your face. Dream on, wanker.”

sch 9/16 

  

Thursday, September 17, 2026

September Is Now August Part Two

Nothing is going on here. I have spent the last few days on my project, when I was supposed to be doing other things. I have left the apartment onlly to make it to the convenience store. Plenty of groceries in the apartment. The heat has been leading me back into the bad habit of napping. I did get through last week's mail.

I have talked to CC and KH. I need to call E and Paul S. DM did not return my call. 

News from Indiana I like to share. 

 The Indiana-Based Bourbon Brand That Outshines E.H. Taylor And Blanton's 

What is that mushroom cloud? 

 Navy installing advanced nuclear microreactor at Indiana command

The Pentagon announced Wednesday that the Navy is planning to install Indiana’s first advanced nuclear micro modular reactor at Naval Weapons Station Crane by September 2028.

The reactor’s deployment helps carry out President Donald Trump’s 2025 executive order calling for the swift integration of nuclear power within the military, with a goal of having at least one working reactor on a military base by Sept. 30, 2028.

 Your 2026 Indianapolis fall theater preview

 A rejection arrived this week:

9/14 

Thank you for sending us "Agnes." We appreciate the opportunity to read your work, but unfortunately this submission was not right for us.

If you decide to submit to us again, please wait at least six months from now before you do so.

Thank you for thinking of us, and—

Best wishes,

The Editors of Copper Nickel

Belated news from Anderson: Workers go on strike at Coca-Cola Consolidated in Anderson - WRTV 


 

sch

Monday, August 24, 2026

More Ball State Theater for 2026-27

 2026-2027 Season | Ball State University for the full list.

Let us see if I can get to the ones that interest me:

Tartuffe

By Jean-Baptiste Molière, adapted by Richard Wilbur
Directed by Karen Kessler and Kathy Logelin

February 12-13 and 17-20 at 7:30 p.m. | February 14 and 20-21 at 2:30 p.m. | Performing Arts Center - Proscenium Theatre

Sharp, witty, and bitingly relevant, Tartuffe is a masterclass in comedic satire. When the wealthy Orgon falls under the spell of Tartuffe—a sanctimonious fraud posing as a man of great piety—his entire household is thrown into chaos.

As Tartuffe schemes to marry Orgon’s daughter, seduce his wife, and seize control of the family fortune, the rest of the household races to expose the truth. What follows is a fast-moving comedy of deception, hypocrisy, and willful blindness. With razor-sharp language and enduring insight, Tartuffe reveals the dangers of believing what we want to believe—even in the face of overwhelming evidence.

TARTUFFE (WILBUR) is presented by arrangement with Concord Theatricals on behalf of Dramatists Play Service. www.concordtheatricals.com

Holmes is Where the Heart Is

By David Taylor Little
Directed by Veronica Santoyo

October 1-4 and 6-8 at 7:30 p.m. | October 3 at 2:30 p.m. | Arts and Journalism Building, Room 225

In postwar London, a sharp-witted private investigator finds herself haunted by voices from her favorite Sherlock Holmes radio broadcasts—clues that may be guiding her toward the truth… or pulling her further from it. As she and her sister race to solve a high-stakes mystery, they must navigate a world that doubts women detectives at every turn. But when instinct, intellect, and imagination collide, the line between inspiration and obsession begins to blur. Suspenseful, witty, and full of intrigue, Holmes Is Where the Heart Is is a clever homage to classic detective stories—reimagined through a fresh and fiercely determined lens. 

Fall Short Play Series
The Fall Short Play Series features multiple short plays performed in repertory directed by junior-level students. 

  • Apocalypse Road Trip
    By Wren Aubrey Latham
    Directed by Mason Luellen
    October 20-25 at 7:30 p.m.  | Art and Journalism Building, Room 225

    When the world ends, Mitchy and Quinn hit the road in a battered 2011 Jeep Wrangler they call ‘The Big Lebowski.’ With humor, heart, and plenty of detours, their journey through a ruined landscape becomes a search for meaning, connection, and a reason to keep going—even at the end of everything. 
  • The Proposal
    By Anton Chekhov, Julius West
    Directed by Tyler Bennett
    October 20-25 at 7:30 p.m. | Art and Journalism Building, Room 225

    A marriage proposal goes wildly off the rails when a nervous young farmer and his intended bride spiral into a series of ridiculous arguments over land, pride, and family honor. Tempers flare, nerves fray, and the engagement teeters—yet somehow, love (or stubbornness) wins out. Fast, sharp, and delightfully absurd, The Proposal is a comic classic about how romance and conflict often arrive hand in hand. 

 

sch 

  

Sunday, August 16, 2026

Movies and Theater, Muncie & Anderson; Books Worth Noting; Kit Marlowe Dies, Again

Ball State's Emens Theater calendar: Upcoming Events at Emens Auditorium.

 Anderson's Paramount Theater is showing movies again! A wondrous place to see movies. I wish more of the films rose to the ocassion.

Movies, movies, movies! Anderson's Paramount Theatre offers slate of free famous films (heraldbulletin.com)

I have a beein in my bonnet about Hollywood remaking movies - instead of recycling well-done material into second-rate reboots, why not plunder older IP? 

Other than Warren Williams, Barbara Stanwyck & Joan Blondell being dead?
 

 Books: The Curse of Queen Kelly (Film Comment)

 Bruce Dern ruined Robert Redford's The Great Gatsby for when I read someone saying Bern should have played Gatsby. Yes, that would've been so much more interesting.

‘I turned down Gandhi because I’m terrified of snakes’: the amazing movie memories of Bruce Dern  (The Guardian) 

I have a fondness for Llosa & Irvine Welsh & Téa Obreh & Kit Marlowe: 

I Give You My Silence by Mario Vargas Llosa review – Nobel laureate’s final novel is a love letter to Peru (The Guardian)

When I Give You My Silence was published in Spanish in 2023 its author, the Peruvian Nobel laureate Mario Vargas Llosa, rightly predicted that it would be his final novel. He died last year at the age of 89. I Give You My Silence may have been completed with the spectre of death approaching, but there is nothing morbid about this book, which is an eccentric love letter to Vargas Llosa’s native country and, in particular, its music.

Can Nothing Save Us? by Irvine Welsh review – US family saga is a late-career triumph  (The Guardian)

Irvine Welsh’s 16th novel Can Nothing Save Us? comes as something of a surprise. An epic American family saga, it explores a collective emotional malaise at the heart of a great power in decline. This is a bold and ambitious work, in which Welsh deftly shifts point of view with confidence and conviction: his ability to jump generations and to capture the voices and feelings of his disparate cast of characters is at times quite astonishing.  

A History of the Novel in Britain by Philip Hensher review – a masterpiece of criticism (The Guardian)

In his opening paragraph, Philip Hensher declares that a novel not only “tells a good story” but is a good story in itself. We could extend that neat formula to include this book, which is not only a masterful account of fiction since 1719, when Daniel Defoe set Robinson Crusoe down on his desert island, but is itself a wonderful read. There is nothing dreary here; no sense of being back in the seminar room taking notes. Instead it is 600 pages of deep pleasure, an excuse to revisit old literary loves and be reminded of ones that have slipped from view.

***

Hensher never falls into crankiness, but he is unafraid to point out home truths. Such as the fact that so much of the pleased-with-itself “experimentalism” of the 1960 to 1980 period was merely a retread of things that had been done better before. Tickled by the clever wheeze of having central characters with no name? Fanny Burney was already doing that in 1814. Keen on using fragmentary collage to signal modernity? That blustery old fogey Evelyn Waugh got there first with Vile Bodies (1930). As for self-reflexivity, that device by which the novelist comments on the process of writing a novel, you should go back to Fielding.

Téa Obreht on Writing a Layered, Intertextual Tale of the American West (Literary Hub) - a delightful writer.

From Marquis de Sade to Grand Theft Auto, a Brief History of Depravity (Literary Hub). I have understood the French fascination with Sade. It seems to fall in line with their admiration of Jerry Lewis. The essay is in good company, Camus started with Sade in The Rebel. I think he was  faker, living in his head, but that might be the point of the essay. He let out all the demons.


Interview with Stephen Greenblatt on the Death of Christopher Marlowe in 1593:


 

 sch

   

Friday, May 8, 2026

Muncie Arts

 Why aren't other cities (looking at you, Anderson) doing these things?

 Connecting the Dots: How Muncie is Building Its Creative Corridor (WLBC)

The idea didn’t appear overnight. It took the input of hundreds of individuals, hours and hours of research and planning, and applications for funding. All of the feedback, suggestions, and big visions came straight from the community.

In 2024, The Community Foundation of Muncie and Delaware County brought together artists, organizations, developers, and residents to ask a simple question: What would it take to make our arts community stronger, more accessible, and more connected?

More than 300 voices helped shape the answer.

That work became the Creative Space Action Plan—a roadmap grounded in community input and focused on expanding access, elevating what we have, supporting artists, and building a more unified creative ecosystem.

Since then, progress has been steady.

Partnerships have formed. Infrastructure improvements have begun. A shared vision has taken hold: a Creative Corridor that links downtown Muncie with Ball State University and Minnetrista, creating a more seamless and welcoming experience for residents and visitors. Phases 1 and 2 focused on foundational supports, including the creation of a partner network and leadership group, reimagination of MuncieArts as an arts service organization, and investment in downtown infrastructure to serve as a backdrop for a vibrant arts hub in Muncie.

Affordability: From silver costs, to suppliers, to advertisements for a Muncie jewelry maker (Indiana Public Radio)

 In preparation for Mother’s Day, Heidi Hale, Founder of HeidiJHale Designs, would typically face online challenges, including not getting enough orders in early enough. 

“We are living in an Amazon Prime world, but what we have to remind them is we’re either taking a loved one’s handwriting, thumbprint, [or] picture, and we’re creating something from scratch,” Hale said. “Nothing is mass produced.” 

I have been in this place, and was impressed. One year when KH came down from Toronto, I took him to the place, and he was also impressed.

Downtown Muncie Announces Brink of Summer ArtsWalk + Flower Hour on June 4 (WLBC)

Downtown Muncie’s most-anticipated spring evening returns on Thursday, June 4, 2026 — the Brink of Summer ArtsWalk + Flower Hour.

Presented by the Community Foundation of Muncie & Delaware County, the Brink of Summer ArtsWalk + Flower Hour runs from 5–8 p.m.

A special edition of the monthly First Thursday series, Brink of Summer ArtsWalk is a community-wide celebration of the arts, local makers, and the vibrant culture of Downtown Muncie. This year’s event features an expanded lineup of programming for attendees of all ages.

Flower Hour, presented by Wise Country Market with flowers provided by Normandy Flower Shop, invites participants to explore Downtown Muncie and collect blooms from 10 different locations to build their own one-of-a-kind bouquet.

You can purchase Flower Hour tickets in advance online or day-of at the event. Physical, printed tickets allow you to start your Flower Hour journey, and they can be picked up, if you purchased them online, or purchased in-person at the DWNTWN tent at the corner of Walnut and Charles Street.

Another highlight of this year’s event is the Steamroller Printmaking Experience, produced by Tribune Showprint with a roller provided by MacAllister Rentals. Local and regional printmakers will create oversized prints using a steamroller as a press, and community members are invited to participate using pre-made blocks. 

And at the other end: Ball State's The Chug bar owner plans to stay amid Village changes. (Well, they used to have bands. I once saw Professor Oak and the Hurricanes there.)

And because I have no other place to put this and have sat on it long enough, and being somewhat theater related makes it arts related: Award-winning actor Hugh Jackman speaks at Ball State University spring 2026 commencement ceremony.  I think this puts Ball State on the radar.  A blip in the night? 

sch 5/7 

Monday, April 27, 2026

Muncie Life: 4/26 - 4/27; Ringo Starr Back and So Is Political Violence.

 Yesterday started off both as a mess and something good. I missed my ride - got the time he was coming completely screwed up in my head. However, I felt well enough to go to church, so I started walking. Just to prove that I could. 

The problems erupted in the evening. After a nap and a light dinner. I did not get to sleep until around 4 AM. I got some reading done. The email attended, but mostly it was a lot of hot baths. All I can say of that is that I got started on the introduction to Adam Smith's Theory of Moral Sentiments. 

The best thing was a long chat on the telephone with J. I like to think I amuse her.

Trump's trip to the correspondent's dinner got interrupted; he seems to have never been in danger. He is reaping what he sowed - hatred breeds violence. Can we survive his ugliness?

Up at nine this morning, a trip to the convenience store, and finishing off this blog post. I also did one for the new writing blog. 

Son of Nobody by Yann Martel review – Life of Pi author discovers a long-lost poem from Troy (The Guardian). Let me know what Martel was doing after Life of Pi.

Latest Ringo Starr album review. I had already heard the single and thought it was great. But who can dislike Ringo? This is the single:


 Also from The Guardian: To see or not to see? Every single Shakespeare play – ranked! Proving I love lists, and this one supports Allan Bloom's opinion of what are the greatest plays of Shakespeare.

WXRT - the Chicago station I listened to in law school and what supplied the music for yesterday.

What a Muslim folk trickster can teach us about the danger of holding a single worldview. Being ignorant of this character, I read the essay. It is the trickster character archetype, but maybe a little more funny than the usual. A good reminder that right makes might; also, that the canny beat the arrogant.

History is full of powerful actors who believed the world’s complexity could be overcome by will and might. Hoja has been subverting confident authorities for at least seven centuries, while refusing to be pinned down, even as a hero. If his tales can be said to have an overall lesson, it is against the comfort of easy answers.

Declaring hard power as all that matters, as Miller has done, doesn’t just mean ignoring others’ humanity – it also means ignoring our own human capacity for curiosity and intellectual humility. 

Another reminder:


Latest attack threatening President Trump reflects rising political violence in US (The Conversation)

There are several important drivers of political violence at work in the U.S. today, according to my own research and research by other scholars. The United States is currently very politically polarized, meaning that Americans are sharply divided against one another along partisan lines. They are suspicious and hostile toward one another, and this produces a tense and volatile environment for politics and public life. This has produced a “zero-sum” environment in which every election and political contest is a “do or die” moment.

What stands out to me is the moral dimension of polarization in the U.S. Each side views members of the other party not as merely having a different view on politics but rather as evil or immoral. The polarized environment has made political violence more normalized. It has also dampened public backlash against political violence when it occurs. This makes political violence more likely.

Political rhetoric has become much more divisive and violent in nature. This works hand in hand with polarization and helps to further normalize political violence. In particular, when politicians use demonizing or dehumanizing rhetoric to attack their opponents – for example, using words that depict their opponents as subhuman – this fosters extremism and helps motivate extremists to hurt their opponents physically.

Disinformation is also an important driver of political violence. A number of people who have engaged in recent acts of political violence seem to have been motivated by conspiracy theories and other forms of disinformation, often gleaned from social media. Disinformation plays a particularly important role in the context of social media communities, where people are exposed to large amounts of disinformation and are hermetically sealed off from other sources that might challenge their worldview. This facilitates radicalization and has been shown to fuel political violence in some cases.

Finally, I think an important factor is also the current assault on democratic norms and democratic institutions in the United States. U.S. democracy is experiencing pressures that are unprecedented in the modern era. This has had a very damaging effect on Americans’ trust in government, confidence in democratic institutions and value for democratic rule itself.

My work shows that individuals who are skeptical about democracy are much more likely to express support or tolerance for political violence. 

 Chuck Todd posted a video this morning with an indictment of the health of our political life and a plea for a better America. I agree with him, but I doubt if either of us will get the result we want.


 No Violence. No Demagoguery. No Kings. (The Bulwark) points out what MAGA is doing with Saturday's incident already.

And we should be proud to be part of a movement that will not be cowed by attempts at intimidation. The pro-democracy movement will resist efforts by this administration and its MAGA minions to use Saturday night as an excuse to criminalize political dissent, silence legitimate criticism, and curtail our civil liberties.

Such efforts got underway within hours of the shooting at the Washington Hilton.

On Sunday morning, House Judiciary Committee Chairman Jim Jordan (R-Ohio) said, “I don’t think this should be lost on anyone . . . that we have a third assassination attempt on President Trump—in that same week we learn that the Southern Poverty Law Center has been paying and generating hate.”

I’d say in response that I don’t think it should be lost on anyone that this is mere demagoguery in defense of the baseless indictment of the Southern Poverty Law Center, and in defense of using Congress’s investigative powers, as Jordan intends to do, to abet DOJ. Of course Jordan doesn’t quite say that there is any connection between the shooter and the SPLC. But he implies one that should not “be lost on anyone.” This is pretty classic McCarthyism—or, for that matter, Trumpism.

Meanwhile, Sen. Ron Johnson (R-Wisc.) tried to use Saturday night’s incident as an excuse not just to get new funding for the Department of Homeland Security but to increase the power of the Senate Republican majority: “At a moment of national danger, if Democrats refuse to fund DHS, I would say this would be the time to nuke the filibuster for good.”

In fact, Democrats are refusing to provide new funds not for the whole of DHS but merely for Immigration and Customs Enforcement and the Border Patrol, neither of which has anything to do with Saturday’s shooting, but which have a lot to do with the administration intimidating opponents. But Trump wants more money for those agencies, and he wants to get rid of the filibuster. This fake “moment of national emergency” is the excuse.

And Speaker Mike Johnson intends to try once again this week to move legislation in the House reauthorizing Section 702 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act without any real civil liberties safeguards.1 Expect to see him and his lieutenants use this “moment of national danger” to try to overcome opposition to the bill, even though there’s no connection between Section 702 and the events of Saturday night.

More broadly, we should expect a sustained effort in the days and weeks to come to intimidate and silence critics of the Trump administration in the same vein as the notorious National Security Presidential Memorandum 7, “Countering Domestic Terrorism and Organized Political Violence,” issued after the assassination of Charlie Kirk. There will be attempts to justify further investigation, chilling, and criminalizing of speech as part of a crackdown on “domestic terrorism.” According to NSPM-7, one of the “common threads animating this violent conduct” is “anti-Christianity.” So President Trump has already called Cole Tomas Allen “anti-Christian”—though as it happens he was active in a Christian group at college, and spends considerable time in his manifesto trying to justify his actions by appealing to scripture. 

The plan is that I am going to the grocery and then to a movie. Trying to break things up today. I want to work ont he blogs today and tomorrow. 

 sch


Thursday, March 26, 2026

Neglected Notes

 Some items AI have been sitting for so long that I am just going to list them with my apologies:

 Broad Ripple Review - Winter 2026 Issue: What We Carry

Calm Sea and Hard Faring by Yiyun Li (The New Yorker and might be behind a paywall).

It was possible to find out about Jude’s friends, but Lilian refrained. Her own best friend from middle school, upon learning of Jude’s death, six years after Oscar’s, had e-mailed, reminiscing about their school days in Beijing. In the hot months, they would buy ice pops from the dining hall for three fen each. The ice pops, colored with yellow food dye, were, in reality, more gray than yellow, offering only a hint of sweetness, and a few times they’d found remnants of vegetable leaves frozen inside. Once, they pooled their money and bought an ice-cream bar in the shape of a snowman, but before they could take a bite the snowman loosened itself from the stick and fell. It had cost sixty fen—twenty ice pops to while away many lunch breaks! They squatted in the sun and watched the snowman melt. Soon, ants congregated.

Lilian’s friend had made a fortune in real estate; still, nothing would take the astonishing sting off that loss. Lilian was touched and replied that she, too, remembered the snowman. Of her children’s deaths, she could say nothing, so she quoted a few lines of a third-century poem from the Jin dynasty: “Those who have accompanied the funeral procession / Are now ready to return home / The sorrow remains for the family / Others have begun to sing / What’s so exceptional about dying / But to entrust your body to the mountain?”

 Unbound: A Collection of Indiana Stories

Hell’s Belle: A True Crime Dark Comedy about Indiana’s First Serial Killer by Amalia Howard is coming to the Shelton Auditorium Apr 23 – May 3.

 

sch

Sunday, March 15, 2026

Recent Readings: 3/10 - 3/15

The lack of energy, the weariness brought about by health issues, extended to reading much online (and even less offline). The following comes (mostly) from the past few days.

And Trump's War continues insanely along: Dismay as ancient heritage sites across Iran damaged in US-Israel bombing. Why did Congress let a man known best for his irresponsibility continue this misadventure of putting other people's lives on the line?

 They make the minds behind Vietnam the best and brightest. Cheney and Rumsfield look like geniuses. I can blame the guys for Vietnam for their arrogance - that was born of ignorance. Bush's team thought they were no longer bound by history. Trump thinks he makes reality even more than the Bushies did.
 
A thought that has recently occurred to me is that we have been repeating Vietnam - Grenada, Iraq, Afghanistan, and now Iran. Maybe it is an open sore in the psyche of Republicans. 
 
They know no history. We started the Iranian problem in 1953. Apparently, they do not understand geography. I feel drained and achy, so my mind is not in its best state. We may be American rarities - we know a little history, we know a little geography; we know what did not work, we know one size does not fit all.  

The Times of Israel has coverage that needs your attention. 

International law and the Iran war (The Article)

An extraordinary social video came out of the White House last week, a mix of actual “strike footage” from Iran, illustrating the promised “death and destruction all day long”, alongside clips from Top Gun, Spiderman and (perhaps a nod at Trump’s Scottish ancestry) Braveheart.  Entitled Justice the American Way, its moral depravity is striking. Just as Archbishop Blaise Cupich of Chicago wrote in response, it depicted a “real war with real death and real suffering being treated like it’s a video game”: an “American way” which ignores the very existence of international law and the values it attempts to preserve.   Pete Hegseth, self-styled US Secretary of State for War, a man responsible for the largest military force in the world, both approved it and appeared in it.  Archbishop Cupich’s is a refreshingly clear voice of condemnation, with his focus on the victims of war.

How can a 79-year-old have the morality of a seven-year old? More importantly, what does such moral bankruptcy say about this country? 


 Perhaps it's not our leaders who fool us but ourselves?

To Be, or Not to Be, Misunderstood (LARB) by Robert N. Wilson changes my reading of Hamlet.

In Hamlet’s soliloquy, he is considering whether the wise choice is to stop caring about bad things you probably can’t change, as the widely beloved Serenity Prayer recommends. The alternative to such acceptance, Hamlet says, is “to take arms against a sea of troubles, / And by opposing end them.” That doesn’t sound like suicide, which would be more like surrendering.

The other crucially misunderstood word in the soliloquy is “quietus.” Hamlet says: “For who would bear the whips and scorns of time, […] When he himself might his quietus make / With a bare bodkin?” People generally assume that when Hamlet considers making “his quietus […] with a bare bodkin,” he is envisioning stabbing himself with a dagger, because they think “quietus” refers to the silence of the grave—“resting in peace,” as the familiar funeral language puts it, and as Hamlet’s dying line “The rest is silence” might seem to confirm. But “quietus” didn’t necessarily indicate quiet; it was a legal term for a debt paid off (“quietus est,” which translates to “he is quit,” would then be written on the loan document). It meant getting even (as when we lament “unrequited love,” love that’s not repaid in kind). Shakespeare’s only other use of the word is in the last line of Sonnet 126, where “quietus” signals a settling of accounts.

Big Men and Little People: Two recent books on Idi Amin’s Uganda present an African mirror for Trump’s United States to see itself. (LARB) by  Samuel Fury Childs Daly makes a comparison that, by the end of the review, does stand up. 

THE BEST HISTORICAL analogue for Donald Trump probably isn’t an American. It also isn’t one of the great villains of 20th-century Europe, despite a long and tired debate about his relationship to fascism. Rather, Trump’s most obvious predecessor comes from one of the “shithole countries” in Africa he disdains: General Idi Amin, the autocrat who ruled Uganda from 1971 to 1979. “It is not only the braggadocio, the self-regard, the love for military ceremony,” historian Derek R. Peterson writes in A Popular History of Idi Amin’s Uganda (2025); it’s also the cruelly funny rhetoric, the demonization of immigrants and outsiders, and the political chaos that comes from constantly hounding your rivals and betraying your friends. Amin and Trump carry themselves alike, and they give the same belligerent speeches. They share a catty kind of charisma. Like Amin, Trump tells his supporters he’s fighting for their freedom, all while turning the screws.

Let us hope Trump does not start feeding us to crocodiles.

Not much of a Liza Minelli fan, but I could not resist The Guardian's review of Kids, Wait Till You Hear This! by Liza Minnelli review—a heady brew of gossip, glamour and defiance

 3/14:

The Buried Tombstone, the Melting Iceberg, and the Random Bullet: History, Memory, and Antagonism in Ireland by R.F. Foster  (Hedgehog Review) has much to offer for those interested in Irish history or the writing of history in general. Gore Vidal wrote several times in his essays about America's historical amnesia, and I do not want to question that sharp mind, but the essay suggests another word.

...David Fitzpatrick, has acutely pointed out that the excision of World War I from the national memory was not a case of “amnesia.” The memory of Ireland’s involvement was all around us. Rather than amnesia, the proper diagnosis was aphasia, an inability or refusal to speak because the sound and meaning of words are disassociated. 

Do we not speak of some parts of our history because we have consciously forgotten them, or is it because we cannot associate words like lynching with ourselves? I do not want to excuse MAGA its efforts to literally whitewash American history, but their inability to speak on the cruelties Americans and their governments have imposed on the powerless does not seem like they have forgotten history as much as they can speak about it and maintain their charmless pursuit of an imaginary America.

 From Epstein files to Gaza and Iran: Crisis of world’s conscience (Daily Sabah). KH thought Epstein would be a story that would go away. So did more than a few pundits. That Trump completely mishandled the release of files promised by him during the campaign has helped keep this sore oozing its pus.

Consequently, within such a civilization, it is not surprising that even its most educated and prominent elites can live in ways detached from the societies they inhabit, often operating at unrestrained extremes without perceiving any wrongdoing until their actions are exposed. In such a setting, the value of other people’s lives can effectively be put up for sale. In this hierarchy of worth, the lives of Muslims in particular are often subject to devaluation and distortion. As a result, every attempt to reconcile their proclaimed moral discourse with their actual political practices ends in failure. In truth, consistency does not seem to concern them greatly; what ultimately prevails are their own interests and advantages. Yet the world, taken as a whole, is increasingly growing weary of these contradictions and is gradually becoming less willing to tolerate them.

For this reason, the crisis we are experiencing today is not merely a political or military one. It is a deeper crisis of legitimacy. Humanity has always struggled to establish institutions capable of limiting power and making it accountable. Yet, the point reached today at the global level under modern Western civilization shows that this problem has become – or has been made into – not merely an issue for individual states, but a fundamental problem of the entire international order. The growing unrest in many parts of the world today is not merely a reaction to specific wars or political crises.

In fact, people are witnessing the visible emergence of a sense of injustice that they have long felt deep inside. If the global order continues to treat human life differently depending on geography, religion or political interests, the legitimacy of that order will increasingly erode. History has shown us again and again that no system of power can endure for long once it loses its moral legitimacy. Therefore, the real question that must now be answered is this: can the world establish a new moral order in which the human being, as a valuable and dignified entity, stands at the center rather than power? Perhaps what humanity needs most today is not a new technology, but a moral horizon that enables us to value the life of another as much as our own. For when the life of the other is devalued, even the systems that appear strongest begin to collapse precisely at this weakest point.

Does culture make emotion? (Aeon) got me thinking I still have not caught up with my notes of my group sessions; we are back talking about cognitive disorders caused by emotions. But I think this applies as much to my fiction (and makes this probably the last post containing the "On Writing" tag; I have taken baby steps regarding my new blog).

 This is an example of how cultural givens become cognitive and emotive ‘habits’ that underlie shared emotions but also produce categories, prejudices and ideologies. They are built into our mental makeup and thus may seem inherent in the self. But they are in fact dynamic, cultural ‘patterned practices’. Language itself is one such instance of a patterned practice. What I hear is culturally conditioned. This is the process involved in how I internalise and then voice what seem to be collectively and normatively acceptable, authentic emotional responses to the voices of the world, such as outrage, pride or disgust. They may feel authentic, but they are precisely what can blind me to the complexity of felt experience, and to the lenses through which I inevitably look at others, or even in the mirror – because top-down goes all the way down.

Our eyes wouldn’t adjust to seeing without the lenses. But we have the metacognitive ability to become aware of their shape and understand the conditions of our own apperception, as Boas did and entreated us to do too. ‘I’ can, to an extent, stand beside the ‘we’ of which each of us is such an intricate part. In this way, we may retrieve its hidden or forgotten elements, perhaps overcome prejudices and neuroses, as Freud helped us do, and so help cultivate a healthy, plural, attentive and democratic collectivity.

The Point published Moral Mysteries: Reading Iris Murdoch on her own terms
by Parker Henry. Which reminded me I have not even tried to crack her Golden Notebook, and that time is not on my side. Coming to me during this tortuous Lent and having acquired an idea for a play on philosophical issues, this passage gave me several things:

The fantasies we project are personal. Our stories are necessarily idiosyncratic. I think this is precisely the difference that scares us. But if we have a moral philosophy that moves us away from some abstract capacity to make logical sense of the world and toward imagining the other through personal narrative, are we not saved—at least a little bit—from our loneliness? Perhaps my intuition of loneliness was itself a projection of my ego, which sought to protect me from that fear of getting closer to others. Murdoch recognizes that we may not come to a full understanding of the other, but through loving attention, we can at least glimpse them. “The tragic freedom implied by love is this,” she writes in “The Sublime and the Good”:

that we all have an indefinitely extended capacity to imagine the being of others. Tragic, because there is no prefabricated harmony, and others are, to an extent we never cease discovering, different from ourselves. Nor is there any social totality within which we can come to comprehend differences as placed and reconciled. We only have a segment of the circle. Freedom is exercised in the confrontation by each other, in the context of an infinitely extensible work of imaginative understanding, of two irreducibly dissimilar individuals. Love is the imaginative recognition of, that is respect for, this otherness.

Maybe glimpsing the segment of the circle is just enough to keep us sane.

 Orthodox Christianity teaches that we are to see others as an icon of Christ and to love them; the Other is not an enemy. The Other brings out our selves. As for the play, it gave me the basis for an argument against moral nihilism: monsters lack power of imagination; they are stuck in the stink of their own hatred.

I also decided that the play needed a little bit of David Hume, and to refresh my memory, I resorted to Hume’s Moral Philosophy (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). I find myself in agreement with Hume about revolutions, albeit my route is more Locke; I do not find them incompatible in their results.

Hume’s predecessors famously took opposing positions on whether human nature was essentially selfish or benevolent, some arguing that man was so dominated by self-interested motives that for moral requirements to govern us at all they must serve our interests in some way, and others arguing that uncorrupted human beings naturally care about the weal and woe of others and here morality gets its hold. Hume roundly criticizes Hobbes for his insistence on psychological egoism or something close to it, and for his dismal, violent picture of a state of nature. Yet Hume resists the view of Hutcheson that all moral principles can be reduced to our benevolence, in part because he doubts that benevolence can sufficiently overcome our perfectly normal acquisitiveness. According to Hume’s observation, we are both selfish and humane. We possess greed, and also “limited generosity” — dispositions to kindness and liberality which are more powerfully directed toward kin and friends and less aroused by strangers. While for Hume the condition of humankind in the absence of organized society is not a war of all against all, neither is it the law-governed and highly cooperative domain imagined by Locke. It is a hypothetical condition in which we would care for our friends and cooperate with them, but in which self-interest and preference for friends over strangers would make any wider cooperation impossible. Hume’s empirically-based thesis that we are fundamentally loving, parochial, and also selfish creatures underlies his political philosophy.

In the realm of politics, Hume again takes up an intermediate position. He objects both to the doctrine that a subject must passively obey his government no matter how tyrannical it is and to the Lockean thesis that citizens have a natural right to revolution whenever their rulers violate their contractual commitments to the people. He famously criticizes the notion that all political duties arise from an implicit contract that binds later generations who were not party to the original explicit agreement. Hume maintains that the duty to obey one’s government has an independent origin that parallels that of promissory obligation: both are invented to enable people to live together successfully. On his view, human beings can create a society without government, ordered by conventional rules of ownership, transfer of property by consent, and promise-keeping. We superimpose government on such a pre-civil society when it grows large and prosperous; only then do we need to use political power to enforce these rules of justice in order to preserve social cooperation. So the duty of allegiance to government, far from depending on the duty to fulfill promises, provides needed assurance that promises of all sorts will be kept. The duty to submit to our rulers comes into being because reliable submission is necessary to preserve order. Particular governments are legitimate because of their usefulness in preserving society, not because those who wield power were chosen by God or received promises of obedience from the people. In a long-established civil society, whatever ruler or type of government happens to be in place and successfully maintaining order and justice is legitimate, and is owed allegiance. However, there is some legitimate recourse for victims of tyranny: the people may rightly overthrow any government that is so oppressive as not to provide the benefits (peace and security from injustice) for which governments are formed. In his political essays Hume certainly advocates the sort of constitution that protects the people’s liberties, but he justifies it not based on individual natural rights or contractual obligations but based on the greater long-range good of society.

3/11:

I think I found where people like my sister get their ideas about sharia law: moronic Republicans. 

The most sensible thing I have read about Epstein.

 sch