Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Writing - Questions About Submitting, Flyover Country (Sort of Twice) & Style

 I freely admit there were distractions when I was writing and revising my novella this past few days. Frankly, I lost energy and direction for a couple of hours on both Sunday and Monday.

The following are what I thought worth sharing. I think they show where my head was while I was writing.

Is your writing ready to submit? 7 questions to ask yourself

  1. Is the piece you want to submit a first or early draft?
  2. What’s it about?
  3. Does the piece feel coherent?
  4. Is the writing clear?
  5.  Have you copyedited carefully? 
  6. Have you proofread the piece and checked the guidelines?
  7. Feedback: why, when, and how does it fit in the funnel? 

I took time out to figure out how well my novella hit these marks. Number made me come up with a synopsis that had never been quite formulated in my head. I had to really think about coherence. I did think I had done a good job according to these seven, until I found errors after running the text through more than one spell/grammar checker and eyebaling the text. What I thought had been done carefully turned out to have too many errors. Vanity, vanity all is vanity.

Tom Drury on Writing from Flyover Country (Literary Hub) touches on a subject close to my own ambitions. From the whole essay it was clear the writer was from Iowa. I think it is applicable also to Indiana. I was talking a week or more ago to KH how I found Central and Eastern European writers and Orhan Pamuk insightful and inspirational for my work. Midwest writers are at the edge.

Now, you could say that to be flown over is to be dismissed or neglected (let’s call this the martyr’s position), but seen in another way, seen in the way that I saw it, it was also to be invited or called to; the Milky Way really did seem like a road going somewhere, and I have to believe, without I hope too much romanticization, that those big night skies contributed something essential to my imagination and belief that unusual things might happen in a life. Like all children, I was in the process of figuring out who I might be, and the tabula, as I recall, was pretty rasa. I had little sense of personal history. I once asked one of my elders where our family had come from and I was told Illinois, which was one state east, so this wasn’t the vast family saga I’d been hoping for. Our lives seemed bounded by the necessary.

When I would ask to do something out of the usual, I was often told, “I don’t think that’s necessary,” so I began to see necessity as a cop, keeping me from doing what I wanted to do. I admit I was an insular kid, not to say strange, though maybe a little strange. I was hard of hearing from an early age, and that kind of wraps you in a cocoon and keeps you there. I liked learning, which not everyone did. My mother, who as a young woman had graduated from business college in a nearby city, was keen on education. She acquired the most valuable intellectual resource we had while growing up—a twenty-volume set of The World Book Encyclopedia. An updated Year Book would arrive annually with sheets of perforated stickers that you were supposed to affix within the pages of the original volumes to show which subjects had been updated in a given year, and I remember my mother faithfully clipping those stickers and pressing them into the margins of the related articles so that my siblings and I would not be missing the latest developments in world knowledge. And my father was a reader, of Perry Mason novels and Zane Grey westerns.

So I had books, TV, the radio on which I listened to plays, music, baseball games. I had the sky, the fields, the farm work, the woods and streams. It was enough to get me started, and while it was true that what might be regarded as serious cultural events were happening almost entirely elsewhere, I could see distant forms of culture as more than what we had rather than opposed to what we had. What I’m saying is that the middle of the country of the latter twentieth century was not a bad beginning point for someone dreaming of being a writer—and besides, it’s the only beginning point I have, so I might as well make the most of it.

At Festival America, France's America-Themed Literary Festival (Paris Review) has an American from the Midwest looking at American literature from France. Reading it all was an unexpected hoot. That it reinforces the prejudices of my perspective had nothing to do with my including it here. Just as Captain Renault was surprised by gambling at Rick's Cafe Americain. Seriously, Midwestern writers take note that others, sometimes outside the U.S., are paying attention.

Festival America, which is held every two years, typically invites authors from across the United States, Canada, Mexico, and the Caribbean whose works have recently been translated into French for a series of panels and workshops in Vincennes, a town just outside Paris. But the 2026 lineup was 100 percent from the U.S.A. in honor of the country’s semiquincentennial. Among those invited were Alison Bechdel, Tommy Orange, Viet Thanh Nguyen, Karen Russell, Patrick Radden Keefe, and many more of our nation’s best-known working writers, plus my husband, Jake, who was suffering from an acute case of impostor syndrome. 

***

One of the panelists was Sébastien Bonifay, a Corsican writer and bookseller who traveled to the U.S. more than twenty times to visit his favorite American authors at their homes, often for days at a time. His recent book, (Not) Born in the USA, recounts meetings with James Ellroy, Chris Offutt, Donald Ray Pollock, Stuart Dybek, James McBride, and more. These are known names, if not exactly those an American would pick. “The literature that nourishes me,” he said, “is an American literature that Americans don’t like.”

He called it “a literature of the margins,” and panelists riffed on what those rough edges were. One placed marginal American literature in a lineage of countercultures that rail against l’establishment (anglicism, pejorative)—rock and roll, psychedelia, punk. Another said that the United States has two literatures: one of “the coasts” and one of “the other,” rarely published but often excellent. This thrilling literature of the margins was often published by universities, which, the panelist said, “have wonderful presses.” It didn’t matter that this type of book didn’t always achieve mainstream acclaim; the panelists seemed to trust their own taste. 

Discipline is especially for Holidays--Dey (FreedomFiction.com on Patreon) was read and then re-read while I felt like I was on a death march this weekend. I did finish the work. Now I want (need) to do something else. Not that I am burned out on writing, but I am tired. This is stuff that every creative person should keep in mind. I know I am trying to do better at enjoying life beyond writing having read it.

Discipline does not mean working relentlessly or turning every passion into an obligation. I am a victim of this. I took it upon myself to push the limits of FreedomFiction.com and myself and the turnaround times for independent publishing. I mean—there is no revenue model since 18+ years and we all are in it for the love of the game and the genre. So when I imagined it as a profession---things felt uneasy and unwelcome. I abhorred getting up and checking the email and pending submissions and the equally tall ready to be published lists. Holding multiple full-time jobs is like sailing in multiple boats while also trying to fish and navigate. It's bound to drown you or at least dunk you in the cold sea to wake you up to reality.

Well—creativity deserves time and nourishment as well as commitment and focus. My vision was to collaborate and co-create. Instead I was becoming a mechanical mill worker. Editorial work is not technical alone—it is creative too—to imagine the author’s perspective and also to accommodate the various thoughts and outlooks so that they all fit cohesively on a single platform without shoving out the other ideas in other narratives.

Creative work means maintaining a relationship with the things that matter to us, even when life becomes busy, all the while staying true to the vocation of author by continuing to write something, anything daily. A writer does not necessarily have to complete a chapter every day. Perhaps a few paragraphs, a page of notes, an observation recorded in a journal or even ten minutes spent developing an idea are enough to keep the creative mind engaged.

The real danger is not missing a day or two. It is allowing an occasional break to become a permanent excuse. Creative habits depend on continuity. The more frequently we return to our craft, the easier it becomes to remain connected with it.

Waiting for the perfect mood, the perfect environment or the perfect working day often means waiting indefinitely.

Pilgrimage by Patrick Nathan (Entertainment, Weakly) almost did not make my cut for this post. It is a great essay about Cezanne and painting. Seriously, read the thing. It is a wonderful piece of writing that informed me more about Cezzane than most anything else I have read. See, painters fascinate me because I have trouble drawing stick figures. Why it is here is because Mr. Nathan brings style out of painting and spreads it around, even into writing. I do not think of myself as a stylist, so it is a case of artistic envy that brought it into this post.

This wandering consciousness, this aimless soul, is precisely what seems present in great work that’s missing from its creator. At some point, a no-one’s soul finds its way through the artist and breathes itself into the novel or the painting or the symphony — where it remains. I’m not sure there’s a better way to understand just how devastating it feels to finish something you know is great. For a moment, you belonged to everything; then your own work took it away from you.

This is why writers (why I) obsess over style — where it comes from, what it looks like, how you sign your name on the same common paper everyone else uses, yet expect it to look yours.

Style is why you roam the world, whether in body or spirit, looking at paintings, reading and rereading novels, listening to music. These things offer pleasures on their own, obviously, but as a writer you want more: the proof, in the ink, that someone else could do it.

Now one last thing: writers write, so get to it. 

sch 11/17 

   

 

   

No comments:

Post a Comment

Please feel free to comment