Wednesday, October 14, 2026

Cormac McCarthy Materials & "East of Eden" Reviews

 Best Cormac McCarthy Books: Every Essential Novel Ranked

I read them in the order not prescribed in the article. And all it did was wet my appettite for more. 

 


'East of Eden' Was an Instant Bestseller in 1952—But Critics Were Divided for These Reasons 

I agree the Cain & Abel plot is heavy-handed; it may be why I do not want to re-read the novel.

AK Blakemore: ‘The Goldfinch by Donna Tartt was extremely silly and bad’ ( The Guardian) makes a couple of interesting points.

The book that changed me as a teenager
I studied F Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby for my English GCSE and it entirely reshaped my brain. I still think it’s about as near to perfect as it’s possible for a novel to be. All the stupid loveliness and yearning in the world, distilled down into image after image, with a core of white-hot rage, at the way extreme wealth enables – necessitates, really – extreme cruelty. There’s functional alcoholism, and then there’s whatever Fitzgerald was doing in 1923. Everyone should read it.

Part of me is perhaps too contrarian. Maybe I have seen too many film adaptions that feel as if they missed the mark that I now attribute to the novel. Must it be read? Certainly.

 The book I could never read again
The Sun Also Rises. I was worryingly into Ernest Hemingway, for a teenage girl, whereas now I think he’s a bit of a pillock.

The book I discovered later in life
I’m 35 so I flatter myself nothing I could say really counts, but: I thought I’d use my maternity leave to finally give some Donna Tartt a go. I staggered through The Goldfinch and thought it was extremely silly and bad.

Pillock: UK offensive. 

The Sun Also Rises is a pillock; so is the Hemingway myth. The man seems now a cautionary tale.

I remained enamored of The Goldfinch for combining Dickens and Camus.  But my ardor has cooled.


 

sch 10/11 

 

 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Please feel free to comment